barrow, Local Online News Community, Forums, Chats, For Sale, Classified, Offers, Film Reviews, Events, Motors Sale, Property For Sale Rent, Jobs, Hotels, Taxi, Restaurants, Pubs, Clubs, Pictures, Sports, Charities, Lost Found
  1. Published on: 10/12/2016 03:19 PMReported by: Film Critic
    From the start of 2016, this film has been talked about non-stop. It's debut at the Sundance Film Festival in January saw sold-out screenings and standing ovations BEFORE the film. The reviews from the film sounded fairly positive, but nothing that mirrored the anticipation for Oscar success.

    For me, this sounded like a film that was going to be an incredibly one-sided story with no subtlety in it whatsoever. With all the discussions from last years Oscars being labelled as 'white-washing', this film to me felt like a response to that, and they are expecting to get some recognition in the awards season, whether they deserve it or not. That therefore made me apprehensive to go and see it.
    After seeing the trailer, I saw some promise in terms of its film-making. That being said, the in-your-face content was noticeable.

    After weighing up everything else, I felt it was right to see it and make my own assumption of it and that I should never separate art from the artists involved.

    In the end, I am sort of glad I did. It is always to criticize a film portraying a topic that you pretty much have to tread carefully. But I feel I am confident in giving the review it deserves.

    I must mention that it is the directorial debut for Nate Parker, who also stars as the main character. Also, while it is billing itself as a true story, it is using that term loosely. There is little information on the events or characters the film is portraying. So there is a lot of gaps to fill, and Parker does not hold up on what is left for the imagination.

    The imagery is most certainly strong, powerful, graphic, and at times gory. There were times where I could see some violent moments feeling gratuitous. But most of it seemed to mean something to the story, as the tone was pretty strong anyway.
    There is some really nice cinematography throughout, with many well constructed haunting images. But there were some oddly timed metaphorical imagery, that while it being shot well, did not seem to make as much sense as I felt it was trying to.
    As for the story, the first two acts are developed well, I enjoyed the performances and where it was going. However the third act seems to take a major shift in tone with the story and the motives of the characters. That putt me off as I felt the final third was an unrated-version of the story I was just watching.

    The performances on the whole very good and realistic. I have to give my due to Nate Parker. You can totally see the passion in this project within the performance. It is consistently strong and carries the film well to make the overall experience worthwhile.
    I was really surprised to Armie Hammer in this. Despite all the coverage I have been reading and hearing, his name never seemed to crop up anywhere. His performance was pretty good. I felt I connected well with his on-screen partnership with Parker's character.
    It was great to see Jackie Earle Hayley play a disgusting character as he has done that really well in the past. Other performances that were worth mentioning were the ones from Penelope Ann-Miller and Aja Naomi King.

    What I think is the main fault with this, is the lack of depth to the story, characters and the story structure being quite conventional and cliched. In some way, it felt like a TV movie. What I mean by that, is that TV movies usually go for spiritually uplifting or emotional stories and execute in a way that feels that they are forcing us to feel like this. The Birth Of A Nation does that, but not as extreme as most TV movies do.

    It is still a good film with a lot of ambition, especially in the imagery. But I think it lacks of depth compared with something like '12 Years A Slave' will not make this as memorable. A directorial debut is never an easy one, and I think that was the main thing lacking in Parker's film.
    Nevertheless, I think you should see it for the ambition, if you are interested in this particular subject, and if you want to know what all the fuss is about.

    I think if it was done with a bit more experience behind the camera, then I think we would have been the seeing an Oscar worthy film that I think Parker and his team were aiming for.

    It will probably do better then it would normally have done. It has been made at the right time, and all of its excitement with the studios going a bit nuts on wanting to fund this has given this the coverage that it needs. Fair to play to Parker and his crew, for a solid job.

    Rating: 7/10
     

  2. Your Comments:



You are in: UK / Barrow / North West
Find any Town in the UK, or Use UK map
Local Google MAP for Barrow
Tide Predictions from NTSLF.ORG



User Control Panel

Not a Member? Sign Up!

Login or Register


Film Reviews, Last Cinema Movies, Movies, DVDs
barrowbarrow News


Stats: Qlocal over 500,000 page views a month (google analytics)
barrow Bathroom Suppliesbarrow Bathroom Tapsbarrow Bathroom Furniturebarrow Bathroom Showersbarrow Shower Enclosuresbarrow Bathsbarrow L Shaped Bathbarrow P Shaped Bathbarrow Wet Roomsbarrow Bath Screensbarrow Bath Mixer Tapbarrow Bidet Tapsbarrow Toilet Seatsbarrow Sanitarywarebarrow Combined Toilet Basinbarrow Stovesbarrow Wood Stovesbarrow Home Stovesbarrow Cooker Stovesbarrow Enamel Stovesbarrow Designer Stovesbarrow Contemporary Stovesbarrow Multi Fuel Stovesbarrow Accounts Softwarebarrow Sage Softwarebarrow Sage Line 50barrow Sage Line 200barrow Pegasus Accountsbarrow Access Accountsbarrow Car Servicingbarrow MOTgbarrow Tyresbarrow Car Batterybarrow Exhaustbarrow Journalist Jobsbarrow Reporter Jobsbarrow Writing Jobsbarrow Freelance Writerbarrow Self Employed Jobsbarrow Franchise Businessbarrow Franchise Opportunitiesbarrow Driving Schoolsbarrow Driving Lessonsbarrow Driving Testbarrow Driving Theory Testbarrow Driving Instruction, 0000 barrow Driving Instructor, 0000 barrow Insolvencybarrow Insolvency Servicebarrow Insolvency Servicesbarrow Liquidation Servicebarrow Business Recoverybarrow Insolvency Practitionerbarrow Bankruptcy Servicebarrow Winding Up Petitionbarrow Business Financebarrow Business Recoverybarrow Voluntary Arrangementbarrow Individual Voluntary Arrangementbarrow IVAbarrow Debt Advicebarrow Debt Managementbarrow Company Administrationbarrow Administrationbarrow Corporate Recoverybarrow Corporate Voluntary Arrangementbarrow CVAbarrow Corporate Insolvencybarrow Corporate Liquidationbarrow Members Voluntary Liquidationbarrow MVLbarrow Partnership Voluntary Arrangementbarrow PVAbarrow Tax Demandbarrow Invoice Financebarrow Bridging Financebarrow Vouchersbarrow Dealsbarrow Matalanbarrow Firewoodbarrow Fire Woodbarrow Kiln Dried Hardwoodbarrow Logs For Salebarrow Log Suppliesbarrow Logsbarrow Firewood Logsbarrow Seasoned Logsbarrow Hardwood Logsbarrow Firewood Suppliersbarrow Firewood Log Suppliersbarrow Firewood Dumpy Bagsbarrow Firewood Cratesbarrow Cheap Firewoodbarrow Homefire Logsbarrow Cheap Firewood Logsbarrow Kindle Conesbarrow Pizza Oven Logsbarrow Heating Oilbarrow Home Heating Oilbarrow Red Dieselbarrow White Dieselbarrow Keresenebarrow Commercial Fuelsbarrow Calor Gasbarrow Propane Gasbarrow Butane Gasbarrow Heating Gasbarrow Horse Trainingbarrow Horse Trainerbarrow Horse Whispererbarrow Equine Whispererbarrow Horse Whisperer Victoria Smithbarrow Rattan Garden Furniturebarrow Rattan Furniturebarrow Rattan Sofabarrow Rattan Dining Setbarrow Rattan Directbarrow Cheap Rattan Furniturebarrow Rattan Corner Sofasbarrow Rattan Day Bedsbarrow Rattan Sun Loungersbarrow Rattan Cube Setsbarrow Rattan Bistro Setsbarrow Chimeneasbarrow Firepitsbarrow Patio Heatersbarrow North West Bookkeeping Servicesbarrow Bookkeeping Servicesbarrow Bookkeeperbarrow Self Assessmentbarrow Small Business Helpbarrow Card Payments Processingbarrow Credit Card Processingbarrow Merchant Servicesbarrow Merchant Accountbarrow Merchant Paymentsbarrow Card Machinesbarrow Card Terminalsbarrow Online Paymentsbarrow Worldpaybarrow Bouncy Castlesbarrow Bouncy Castle Hirebarrow Garden Trampolinesbarrow Pramsbarrow Pushchairsbarrow Strollersbarrow Hauck Pramsbarrow Huackbarrow Childrens Trampolinesbarrow Baby Mobilesbarrow Baby Activity Matsbarrow Baby Bedroom Furniturebarrow Childrens Bedroom Furniturebarrow Hygiene Vendingbarrow Washroom Vendingbarrow Air Freshenersbarrow Air Carebarrow Aerosol Systemsbarrow Gel Systemsbarrow Water Savingbarrow Urinal Water Savingbarrow Eco Capsbarrow Sensaflushbarrow Water Managementbarrow Urinal Dosingbarrow Urinal V Screensbarrow Legionella Risk Assessmentbarrow Legionaires Bacterialbarrow Odour Controlbarrow Odour Eliminationbarrow Odour Removalbarrow Airsterilbarrow Hand Carebarrow Hand Creambarrow Hand Soapbarrow Hand Washingbarrow Hand Dryingbarrow Hand Dryersbarrow Electric Hand Dryersbarrow Fast Hand Dryersbarrow Commercial Hand Dryersbarrow Energy Efficient Hand Dryersbarrow Hand Dryer Rentalbarrow Hand Dryer Salesbarrow Paper Towelsbarrow Roller Towelsbarrow Cotton Roller Towelsbarrow Blue Roller Towelsbarrow White Roller Towelsbarrow Janitorial Suppliesbarrow Janitorialbarrow Cleaning Suppliesbarrow Cleaning Productsbarrow Cleaning Equipmentbarrow Office Cleaningbarrow Home Cleaningbarrow Accountantsbarrow Accountancybarrow Accountsbarrow Auditsbarrow Bookkeepingbarrow Management Accountsbarrow VAT Returnsbarrow Business Planningbarrow Cash Flow Planningbarrow Payrollbarrow Pension Reformbarrow Business Start Upbarrow Company Formationsbarrow Tax Advicebarrow Tax Investigationbarrow Company Lawbarrow Outsource FDdbarrow Debt Recovery Helpbarrow CIS Subcontractor Servicebarrow Software Selectionbarrow Sage Accountsbarrow Debt Recovery Servicesbarrow Debt Recoverybarrow Debt Collectionbarrow Outsource Credit Controlbarrow Collection Agencybarrow Debt Collection Agencybarrow Commercial Canopybarrow Steel Canopybarrow Bike Shedsbarrow Bike Storagebarrow Bicycle Storebarrow Bicycle Storagebarrow Bikes Storebarrow Bike Storebarrow Outdoor Canopybarrow Cycle Sheltersbarrow Cycle Shedbarrow Cycle Storagebarrow Cycle Rackbarrow Cycle Compoundbarrow Cycle Solutionsbarrow Scooter Storagebarrow Scooter Shelterbarrow Canopiesbarrow Canopybarrow Play Area Canopybarrow Entrance Canopiesbarrow Entrance Canopybarrow Waiting Shelterbarrow Smoking Shelterbarrow Parent Waiting Shelterbarrow Parent Shelterbarrow Teen Shelterbarrow Nursery Canopybarrow School Canopybarrow Play Canopybarrow Envirolawnbarrow Astroturfbarrow Cheap Astroturfbarrow Artificial Grassbarrow Cheap Artificial Grassbarrow Astro Turfbarrow Artificial Lawnbarrow Fake Grassbarrow Fake Lawnbarrow Fire Stove Glassbarrow Heat Resistant Glassbarrow Fire Glassbarrow Stove Glassbarrow Fire Resistant Glassbarrow Replacement Stove Glassbarrow Glass For Stovesbarrow Spill Kitsbarrow Spill Control Kitsbarrow Spill Kit Refillsbarrow Spill Kit Refill GK6barrow Chemical Spill Kitsbarrow Oil Spill Kitsbarrow Solar Panelsbarrow Solar Panels Costbarrow Solar Heatingbarrow Solar PVbarrow Commercial Solarbarrow Photovoltaicbarrow Dust Matsbarrow Entrance Matsbarrow Reception Matsbarrow Anti Fatigue Matsbarrow Floor Matsbarrow Logo Matsbarrow Washroom Servicesbarrow Principal Washroomsbarrow Washrooms Suppliesbarrow Washrooms Solutionsbarrow Sanitary Disposalbarrow Sanitary Binsbarrow Sani Binsbarrow Lady Binsbarrow Feminine Hygiene Unitsbarrow Sanitary Waste Disposalbarrow Sanitary Wastebarrow Sanitary Unitsbarrow Feminine Unitsbarrow Hygiene Servicesbarrow Sanitary Bin Supplierbarrow Sanitary Bin Rentalbarrow Sanitary Bin Rental Servicesbarrow General Wastebarrow Trade Wastebarrow Commercial Wastebarrow Business Wastebarrow Waste Managementbarrow Waste Collectionbarrow Cardboard Wastebarrow Paper Wastebarrow Plastic Wastebarrow Glass Wastebarrow Biomass Wastebarrow Metal Wastebarrow Confidential Wastebarrow Confidential Waste Servicebarrow On Site Shreddingbarrow Off Site Shreddingbarrow One Off Shreddingbarrow Contract Shreddingbarrow Dental Wastebarrow Dental Waste Disposalbarrow Dental Waste Legislationbarrow Dental Waste Compliancebarrow Accupuncture Wastebarrow Accupuncture Waste Disposalbarrow Accupuncture Waste Collectionbarrow Tattoo Wastebarrow Tattoo Waste Disposalbarrow Sharps Binbarrow Sharps Collectionbarrow Hazardous Sharpsbarrow Non Hazardous Sharpsbarrow Cytotoxic Sharpsbarrow Cytostatic Sharpsbarrow Ink Blockbarrow Wet_Wastebarrow Tattoo Inkbarrow Drug Destructionbarrow Drug Disposalbarrow Drug Denaturingbarrow Unwanted Drugsbarrow Out Of Date Drugsbarrow Pest Controlbarrow Rodent Controlbarrow Bird Controlbarrow Bird Proofingbarrow Guano Controlbarrow Pest Call Outbarrow Pest Preventionbarrow Pest Deterrentbarrow Nursery Wastebarrow Nappy Wastebarrow Nappy Binbarrow Nappy Disposalbarrow Nappy Wheelie Binbarrow Nursery Waste Disposalbarrow Nursery Waste Collectionbarrow Incontinence Padsbarrow Offensive Wastebarrow Human Wastebarrow Nursing Home Wastebarrow Care Home Wastebarrow Hazardous Wastebarrow Infectous Wastebarrow Pharmaceutical Wastebarrow Medicinal Wastebarrow Medicine Wastebarrow Infection Controlbarrow Hand Sanitisersbarrow Clinical Waste Disposalbarrow Clinical Waste Managementbarrow Clinical Waste Policybarrow EA Registrationbarrow Hammocksbarrow Garden Hammocksbarrow Adult Hammocksbarrow Childrens Hammocksbarrow Baby Hammocks