belper, Local Online News Community, Forums, Chats, For Sale, Classified, Offers, Film Reviews, Events, Motors Sale, Property For Sale Rent, Jobs, Hotels, Taxi, Restaurants, Pubs, Clubs, Pictures, Sports, Charities, Lost Found
  1. Published on: 10/12/2016 03:19 PMReported by: Film Critic
    From the start of 2016, this film has been talked about non-stop. It's debut at the Sundance Film Festival in January saw sold-out screenings and standing ovations BEFORE the film. The reviews from the film sounded fairly positive, but nothing that mirrored the anticipation for Oscar success.

    For me, this sounded like a film that was going to be an incredibly one-sided story with no subtlety in it whatsoever. With all the discussions from last years Oscars being labelled as 'white-washing', this film to me felt like a response to that, and they are expecting to get some recognition in the awards season, whether they deserve it or not. That therefore made me apprehensive to go and see it.
    After seeing the trailer, I saw some promise in terms of its film-making. That being said, the in-your-face content was noticeable.

    After weighing up everything else, I felt it was right to see it and make my own assumption of it and that I should never separate art from the artists involved.

    In the end, I am sort of glad I did. It is always to criticize a film portraying a topic that you pretty much have to tread carefully. But I feel I am confident in giving the review it deserves.

    I must mention that it is the directorial debut for Nate Parker, who also stars as the main character. Also, while it is billing itself as a true story, it is using that term loosely. There is little information on the events or characters the film is portraying. So there is a lot of gaps to fill, and Parker does not hold up on what is left for the imagination.

    The imagery is most certainly strong, powerful, graphic, and at times gory. There were times where I could see some violent moments feeling gratuitous. But most of it seemed to mean something to the story, as the tone was pretty strong anyway.
    There is some really nice cinematography throughout, with many well constructed haunting images. But there were some oddly timed metaphorical imagery, that while it being shot well, did not seem to make as much sense as I felt it was trying to.
    As for the story, the first two acts are developed well, I enjoyed the performances and where it was going. However the third act seems to take a major shift in tone with the story and the motives of the characters. That putt me off as I felt the final third was an unrated-version of the story I was just watching.

    The performances on the whole very good and realistic. I have to give my due to Nate Parker. You can totally see the passion in this project within the performance. It is consistently strong and carries the film well to make the overall experience worthwhile.
    I was really surprised to Armie Hammer in this. Despite all the coverage I have been reading and hearing, his name never seemed to crop up anywhere. His performance was pretty good. I felt I connected well with his on-screen partnership with Parker's character.
    It was great to see Jackie Earle Hayley play a disgusting character as he has done that really well in the past. Other performances that were worth mentioning were the ones from Penelope Ann-Miller and Aja Naomi King.

    What I think is the main fault with this, is the lack of depth to the story, characters and the story structure being quite conventional and cliched. In some way, it felt like a TV movie. What I mean by that, is that TV movies usually go for spiritually uplifting or emotional stories and execute in a way that feels that they are forcing us to feel like this. The Birth Of A Nation does that, but not as extreme as most TV movies do.

    It is still a good film with a lot of ambition, especially in the imagery. But I think it lacks of depth compared with something like '12 Years A Slave' will not make this as memorable. A directorial debut is never an easy one, and I think that was the main thing lacking in Parker's film.
    Nevertheless, I think you should see it for the ambition, if you are interested in this particular subject, and if you want to know what all the fuss is about.

    I think if it was done with a bit more experience behind the camera, then I think we would have been the seeing an Oscar worthy film that I think Parker and his team were aiming for.

    It will probably do better then it would normally have done. It has been made at the right time, and all of its excitement with the studios going a bit nuts on wanting to fund this has given this the coverage that it needs. Fair to play to Parker and his crew, for a solid job.

    Rating: 7/10
     

  2. Your Comments:



You are in: UK / Belper / East Midlands
Find any Town in the UK, or Use UK map
Local Google MAP for Belper



User Control Panel

Not a Member? Sign Up!

Login or Register


Film Reviews, Last Cinema Movies, Movies, DVDs
belperbelper News


Stats: Qlocal over 500,000 page views a month (google analytics)
belper Bathroom Suppliesbelper Bathroom Tapsbelper Bathroom Furniturebelper Bathroom Showersbelper Shower Enclosuresbelper Bathsbelper L Shaped Bathbelper P Shaped Bathbelper Wet Roomsbelper Bath Screensbelper Bath Mixer Tapbelper Bidet Tapsbelper Toilet Seatsbelper Sanitarywarebelper Combined Toilet Basinbelper Stovesbelper Wood Stovesbelper Home Stovesbelper Cooker Stovesbelper Enamel Stovesbelper Designer Stovesbelper Contemporary Stovesbelper Multi Fuel Stovesbelper Accounts Softwarebelper Sage Softwarebelper Sage Line 50belper Sage Line 200belper Pegasus Accountsbelper Access Accountsbelper Car Servicingbelper MOTgbelper Tyresbelper Car Batterybelper Exhaustbelper Journalist Jobsbelper Reporter Jobsbelper Writing Jobsbelper Freelance Writerbelper Self Employed Jobsbelper Franchise Businessbelper Franchise Opportunitiesbelper Driving Schoolsbelper Driving Lessonsbelper Driving Testbelper Driving Theory Testbelper Driving Instruction, 0000 belper Driving Instructor, 0000 belper Insolvencybelper Insolvency Servicebelper Insolvency Servicesbelper Liquidation Servicebelper Business Recoverybelper Insolvency Practitionerbelper Bankruptcy Servicebelper Winding Up Petitionbelper Business Financebelper Business Recoverybelper Voluntary Arrangementbelper Individual Voluntary Arrangementbelper IVAbelper Debt Advicebelper Debt Managementbelper Company Administrationbelper Administrationbelper Corporate Recoverybelper Corporate Voluntary Arrangementbelper CVAbelper Corporate Insolvencybelper Corporate Liquidationbelper Members Voluntary Liquidationbelper MVLbelper Partnership Voluntary Arrangementbelper PVAbelper Tax Demandbelper Invoice Financebelper Bridging Financebelper Vouchersbelper Dealsbelper Matalanbelper Firewoodbelper Fire Woodbelper Kiln Dried Hardwoodbelper Logs For Salebelper Log Suppliesbelper Logsbelper Firewood Logsbelper Seasoned Logsbelper Hardwood Logsbelper Firewood Suppliersbelper Firewood Log Suppliersbelper Firewood Dumpy Bagsbelper Firewood Cratesbelper Cheap Firewoodbelper Homefire Logsbelper Cheap Firewood Logsbelper Kindle Conesbelper Pizza Oven Logsbelper Heating Oilbelper Home Heating Oilbelper Red Dieselbelper White Dieselbelper Keresenebelper Commercial Fuelsbelper Calor Gasbelper Propane Gasbelper Butane Gasbelper Heating Gasbelper Horse Trainingbelper Horse Trainerbelper Horse Whispererbelper Equine Whispererbelper Horse Whisperer Victoria Smithbelper Rattan Garden Furniturebelper Rattan Furniturebelper Rattan Sofabelper Rattan Dining Setbelper Rattan Directbelper Cheap Rattan Furniturebelper Rattan Corner Sofasbelper Rattan Day Bedsbelper Rattan Sun Loungersbelper Rattan Cube Setsbelper Rattan Bistro Setsbelper Chimeneasbelper Firepitsbelper Patio Heatersbelper Card Payments Processingbelper Credit Card Processingbelper Merchant Servicesbelper Merchant Accountbelper Merchant Paymentsbelper Card Machinesbelper Card Terminalsbelper Online Paymentsbelper Worldpaybelper Bouncy Castlesbelper Bouncy Castle Hirebelper Garden Trampolinesbelper Pramsbelper Pushchairsbelper Strollersbelper Hauck Pramsbelper Huackbelper Childrens Trampolinesbelper Baby Mobilesbelper Baby Activity Matsbelper Baby Bedroom Furniturebelper Childrens Bedroom Furniturebelper Hygiene Vendingbelper Washroom Vendingbelper Air Freshenersbelper Air Carebelper Aerosol Systemsbelper Gel Systemsbelper Water Savingbelper Urinal Water Savingbelper Eco Capsbelper Sensaflushbelper Water Managementbelper Urinal Dosingbelper Urinal V Screensbelper Legionella Risk Assessmentbelper Legionaires Bacterialbelper Odour Controlbelper Odour Eliminationbelper Odour Removalbelper Airsterilbelper Hand Carebelper Hand Creambelper Hand Soapbelper Hand Washingbelper Hand Dryingbelper Hand Dryersbelper Electric Hand Dryersbelper Fast Hand Dryersbelper Commercial Hand Dryersbelper Energy Efficient Hand Dryersbelper Hand Dryer Rentalbelper Hand Dryer Salesbelper Paper Towelsbelper Roller Towelsbelper Cotton Roller Towelsbelper Blue Roller Towelsbelper White Roller Towelsbelper Janitorial Suppliesbelper Janitorialbelper Cleaning Suppliesbelper Cleaning Productsbelper Cleaning Equipmentbelper Office Cleaningbelper Home Cleaningbelper Debt Recovery Servicesbelper Debt Recoverybelper Debt Collectionbelper Outsource Credit Controlbelper Collection Agencybelper Debt Collection Agencybelper Commercial Canopybelper Steel Canopybelper Bike Shedsbelper Bike Storagebelper Bicycle Storebelper Bicycle Storagebelper Bikes Storebelper Bike Storebelper Outdoor Canopybelper Cycle Sheltersbelper Cycle Shedbelper Cycle Storagebelper Cycle Rackbelper Cycle Compoundbelper Cycle Solutionsbelper Scooter Storagebelper Scooter Shelterbelper Canopiesbelper Canopybelper Play Area Canopybelper Entrance Canopiesbelper Entrance Canopybelper Waiting Shelterbelper Smoking Shelterbelper Parent Waiting Shelterbelper Parent Shelterbelper Teen Shelterbelper Nursery Canopybelper School Canopybelper Play Canopybelper Envirolawnbelper Astroturfbelper Cheap Astroturfbelper Artificial Grassbelper Cheap Artificial Grassbelper Astro Turfbelper Artificial Lawnbelper Fake Grassbelper Fake Lawnbelper Fire Stove Glassbelper Heat Resistant Glassbelper Fire Glassbelper Stove Glassbelper Fire Resistant Glassbelper Replacement Stove Glassbelper Glass For Stovesbelper Spill Kitsbelper Spill Control Kitsbelper Spill Kit Refillsbelper Spill Kit Refill GK6belper Chemical Spill Kitsbelper Oil Spill Kitsbelper Solar Panelsbelper Solar Panels Costbelper Solar Heatingbelper Solar PVbelper Commercial Solarbelper Photovoltaicbelper Dust Matsbelper Entrance Matsbelper Reception Matsbelper Anti Fatigue Matsbelper Floor Matsbelper Logo Matsbelper Washroom Servicesbelper Principal Washroomsbelper Washrooms Suppliesbelper Washrooms Solutionsbelper Sanitary Disposalbelper Sanitary Binsbelper Sani Binsbelper Lady Binsbelper Feminine Hygiene Unitsbelper Sanitary Waste Disposalbelper Sanitary Wastebelper Sanitary Unitsbelper Feminine Unitsbelper Hygiene Servicesbelper Sanitary Bin Supplierbelper Sanitary Bin Rentalbelper Sanitary Bin Rental Servicesbelper General Wastebelper Trade Wastebelper Commercial Wastebelper Business Wastebelper Waste Managementbelper Waste Collectionbelper Cardboard Wastebelper Paper Wastebelper Plastic Wastebelper Glass Wastebelper Biomass Wastebelper Metal Wastebelper Confidential Wastebelper Confidential Waste Servicebelper On Site Shreddingbelper Off Site Shreddingbelper One Off Shreddingbelper Contract Shreddingbelper Dental Wastebelper Dental Waste Disposalbelper Dental Waste Legislationbelper Dental Waste Compliancebelper Accupuncture Wastebelper Accupuncture Waste Disposalbelper Accupuncture Waste Collectionbelper Tattoo Wastebelper Tattoo Waste Disposalbelper Sharps Binbelper Sharps Collectionbelper Hazardous Sharpsbelper Non Hazardous Sharpsbelper Cytotoxic Sharpsbelper Cytostatic Sharpsbelper Ink Blockbelper Wet_Wastebelper Tattoo Inkbelper Drug Destructionbelper Drug Disposalbelper Drug Denaturingbelper Unwanted Drugsbelper Out Of Date Drugsbelper Pest Controlbelper Rodent Controlbelper Bird Controlbelper Bird Proofingbelper Guano Controlbelper Pest Call Outbelper Pest Preventionbelper Pest Deterrentbelper Nursery Wastebelper Nappy Wastebelper Nappy Binbelper Nappy Disposalbelper Nappy Wheelie Binbelper Nursery Waste Disposalbelper Nursery Waste Collectionbelper Incontinence Padsbelper Offensive Wastebelper Human Wastebelper Nursing Home Wastebelper Care Home Wastebelper Hazardous Wastebelper Infectous Wastebelper Pharmaceutical Wastebelper Medicinal Wastebelper Medicine Wastebelper Infection Controlbelper Hand Sanitisersbelper Clinical Waste Disposalbelper Clinical Waste Managementbelper Clinical Waste Policybelper EA Registrationbelper Hammocksbelper Garden Hammocksbelper Adult Hammocksbelper Childrens Hammocksbelper Baby Hammocks